Showing posts with label Black Widow. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Black Widow. Show all posts

Thursday, September 17, 2026

"The Ultimates: Gods and Monsters"

 

            The following is a review of the graphic novel “The Ultimates: Gods and Monsters” as presented in Marvel Ultimate Epic Collection format.

            A year after saving the Earth from an alien invasion, S.H.I.E.L.D.’s superhuman defense team the Ultimates (Steve Rogers/Captain America, Tony Stark/Iron Man, Janet Pym/Wasp, Clint Barton/Hawkeye, Natasha Romanoff/Black Widow, Pietro Maximoff/Quicksilver, and Wanda Maximoff/Scarlet Witch), led by General Nick Fury, continued to fight terrorism. Hank Pym/Giant Man had been expelled from active duty, Thor quit the team, and Bruce Banner/Hulk was imprisoned, but Banner’s identity as the Hulk was withheld from all unauthorized personnel and the general public. Steve and Jan were exploring their relationship following Jan and Hank’s separation following domestic abuse. Tony and Natasha had also begun dating. Hank was trying to find a way back onto the Ultimates under a different codename, workshopping the identity of Ant-Man. Bruce, while in lockup, was working on more potential super soldiers for Ultimates membership, but was meeting with no success. Bruces’s identity as the Hulk was leaked to the press. This proved there was a leak from deep within S.H.I.E.L.D. and shed a bad light on Fury and the Ultimates, who had pretended for over a year to be unaware of the Hulk’s true identity or origin. Steve tracked down Thor, who was the suspected leak, but Thor denied any involvement in leaking Bruce’s identity, knowing that exposing Bruce was basically a death sentence as the Hulk was implicated in mass murder. Bruce went on a highly televised trial as the Hulk, with Matt Murdock defending Bruce. Betty Ross, Bruce’s ex, begged Bruce’s forgiveness, feeling guilty for Bruce turning Bruce into the Hulk, but Bruce refused to forgive Betty. Bruce was found guilty and sentenced to death. Bruce’s execution was carried out by sedating Bruce and setting off a one-megaton bomb, but unknown to S.H.I.E.L.D., Bruce survived the explosion. Tony gave Natasha a suit of armor similar to Tony’s own Iron Man armor. While on a test run, Tony flashily proposed to Natasha. Natasha accepted Tony’s proposal. The Ultimates were called to Europe to meet with the head of S.H.I.E.L.D.’s European Defense Initiative, James Braddock. The Ultimates were introduced to the European super soldiers Brian Braddock/Captain Britain, Umberto Landi/Captain Italy, Carlos Fraile/Captain Spain, and Hugo Etherlinck/Captain France. The Ultimates also met a man claiming to be Gunnar Golmen, head of the Norwegian team, who had been working on technology that had been stolen by his brother Thorlief, the man the Ultimates knew as Thor. Thor had been going throughout Europe aiding in protests using the alleged stolen technology. The Ultimates went to Norway to confront Thor to put an end to Thor’s activities and take the technology back. During the confrontation, Thor claimed that Gunnar was actually Loki, Asgardian God of Mischief, trying to trick the Ultimates. After a battle, the Ultimates, with the aid of the European Defense Initiative super soldiers, were able to subdue Thor. Thor was restrained and placed in a holding cell in the Triskelion. Loki visited Thor in Thor’s imprisonment to gloat and to tell Thor that there was a traitor among the Ultimates.

            Hank joined up with fledgling wannabe superhero team the Defenders (Nighthawk, Black Knight, Hellcat, Power Man, Son of Satan, and Valkyrie. Hank had been trying to give S.H.I.E.L.D. androids Hank called Ultron and Vision Two to aid the Ultimates, but Fury did not want to accept Hank’s gifts. The Defenders were primed to make their big superhero debut, stopping a robbery at a cigarette warehouse. This bust failed miserably, with Nighthawk badly injured, Hank landing in the news indecently exposed, and the perps getting away.

            Jan had been meeting with Hank, unsatisfied in her relationship with Steve. Steve wanted to spend so much of Steve and Jan’s time with Bucky Barnes (Steve’s World War II buddy) and Bucky’s wife Gail (Steve’s ex-fiancĂ© whom Bucky married after Steve was presumed dead), while Jan wanted to spend time with people Jan’s own age. The wolf in the fold and several enemy agents visited Clint’s house and shot Clint and executed Clint’s wife and three kids, then took Clint. Steve and Jan had a fight and Steve left to think. Security footage of the attack on Clint’s house revealed the agents who assaulted Clint and Clint’s family to be led by Steve Rogers. While visiting Greenwood Cemetery with Bucky, Steve was apprehended by a S.H.I.E.L.D. tactical team led by Fury. The Liberators (Colonel, Abomination, Crimson Dynamo, Hurricane, Swarm, Perun, Schizoid Man, and Loki) launched an assault on the United States of America, attacking S.H.I.E.L.D. helicarriers, the Triskelion, and New York City, aided by Hank and Hank’s androids. Natasha revealed herself to be the actual traitor inside the Ultimates. Natasha took out Tony’s butler Jarvis and planned to have Tony wire Natasha money, then execute Tony as well, but Tony revealed the armor that Tony had given Natasha had nanites that Tony could control, and Tony subdued Natasha. Clint managed to escape his captors. Schizoid Man and several agents of the Liberators came to put down Steve, but Jan had already released Steve and Steve and Jan subdued the would-be assassins and went to free Thor, but Thor had already escaped. The Liberators went to Washington, D.C., abducting Spider-Man, the X-Men, and the Fantastic Four. The Ultimates followed and battled the Liberators at the White House, where they were reunited with Hawkeye. The Hulk also made a reappearance and joined the Ultimates as the Ultimates, Nick Fury, and Betty Ross fought to survive against the Liberators. As the battle turned in the favor of the Ultimates, Loki summoned an army. Things looked bad for the United States of America until Thor appeared, aided by an army from Asgard. The two armies fought, with the fate of the country hanging in the balance.

            Retired assassin Mister Nix was called out of retirement to kill Nick Fury. S.H.I.E.L.D. was working on a reserves team for the Ultimates, to add to the core team, or to act as replacements should anything happen to the active members. The Defenders recruited Whiz-Kid to their team.

            Okay, we’ve got the synopsis out of the way, it’s time to move on to my individual segments of this review. We’re going to start, as we always do, with my personal opinions on this book. First off, I’m going to talk about the story. I will say I was not fully pleased with these stories. I thought the first six issues and the annual were great. I totally loved them. It’s once we get to the point where Black Widow takes out Hawkeye’s family where I started to feel offput. I thought executing an innocent woman and three young children, including a baby, was too much. I originally thought the domestic assault in Vol. 1 was bad, this just totally surpassed that on a scale of one-to-totally messed up. And Jan confiding in Hank about her insecurities with Steve just totally ruined my impression of Jan, that Jan would even want to breathe the same air as the man who put Jan in the hospital is beyond me, considering everything that happened between Jan and Hank. The whole battle with the Liberators seemed messy and a little disjointed. The epic-ness of the battle also detracted a little bit from potential story development. All that said, what I did find enjoyable was the trial of the Hulk, the introduction of the European Defense Initiative, the Ultimates versus Thor, the introduction of the Defenders, and the hit on Fury. Next up to discuss is the artwork. I will say that I enjoy Brian Hitch’s work a lot. I love his stylizations; I think they’re totally amazing. I particularly like when he draws closeups of faces, the details he draws are amazing. Sometimes, when he draws characters from a distance, it does go a little wonky, but I generally enjoy his artwork. I will say that Steve Dillon did a fair job with his illustrations, but there’s just a little something about the faces he draws that just doesn’t quite look right. I didn’t find the artwork to be totally offensive, but at the same time, the appeal wasn’t consistent. The next thing I’d like to discuss is the appropriateness of the title. I know, I’m very nitpicky, but I have to do an in-depth assessment of this book, and the title is an important part of that, in my opinion. So, this book was titled “Gods and Monsters.” In my honest opinion, I feel that is a fair title for this book. Considering we have the conflict between Thor and the Asgardians against Loki and his army, as well as Hulk and Abomination as a key focus in this book, the title is an appropriate way to describe this book. And to get even more nitpicky, I will also assess if the cover is appropriate. The cover shows the Ultimates and the European Defense Initiative standing and flying together. I feel like this is a good way to advertise this book. It properly captures the essence of the interior, showing the characters battle-ready. I feel like the marketing for this book was proper and describes and depicts the contents of what the reader can expect when they go to experience this graphic novel. Overall, this wasn’t a terrible graphic novel, in my opinion, but there was just a line that got crossed too far that changed my experience quite drastically, and not for the better, but the illustrations were relatively appealing for the most part of this graphic novel, which did improve the experience immensely.

            Next up on the list of things we’re going to discuss is accessibility. I know I’ve talked about this over seven dozen times by this point, but I know that every time I do a book review, I have new readers who don’t know what I mean by this, so I have to explain myself, so if you’ve been with me before, please bear with me while I go over the meaning of accessibility in application to a graphic novel once again. So, by doing this, I’m asking if a book is accessible, meaning can a person who knows absolutely nothing about the Ultimates or Marvel in general obtain a copy of this book, read it, and understand everything they’ve read based on just the content in this particular volume, with no outside knowledge or context. My answer to that is yes. This book is relatively self-contained. The contents are all thirteen issues of Ultimates 2 and Ultimates Annual #1. This does not tie into any events or crossover into any other comics series. While having read the first volume of The Ultimates helps understand this book more comprehensively, I will not say that I feel like it is required reading. The story starts fresh, not continuing directly from where the previous stories left off while still following the threads established in the first volume of The Ultimates. If you’re interested in starting to read Marvel Comics and have never done so before, while I wouldn’t describe this as the best or perfect place to start your adventure into reading Marvel, I also would not deter you from choosing this volume as your starting point. I would encourage you to read “The Ultimates” #1-13 prior to reading this volume, but I wouldn’t tell you that it’s essential to do so if you just want to read this book.

            Next up on our agenda is the numeric score. This is the part of my review that establishes just how good I feel a book is and is one of the most essential paragraphs in my reviews, but I am aware that some people come to hear about the stories as well, so I wouldn’t say that this is the most important paragraph. Anyway, if you’re new to my reviews, you don’t know how I score books, so I’m going to have to go over that again for those of you joining me for the first time. My system is fairly simple: I score on a scale of exact whole numbers ranging from one through ten. The lowest score I can give is a one, which means that this book is a horrible read that I wish I could go back in time and make it so that I never even knew this book existed, let alone bought or read it. Ten is my highest score, which means that this book is sheer perfection and I will read this book again when I feel the urge and love every second of it every subsequent time, I reexperience this book. A ten has specific requirements for me. It has to have a captivating story that is enjoyable from start to finish. The artwork has to be consistently appealing through every panel of the book. And the title and cover must properly market the majority of the content contained within the pages of the book. We’ve established that this book did not have a story that was enjoyable throughout the entirety of this book, and the artwork did have inconsistencies, but the title and cover were proper representations for this book. So, laying everything out on the table and dishing out my score, what we’re looking at here is… a six. This book was only half enjoyable story-wise, and the art left a little something to be desired, but I do score it on the higher side of midrange.

            Next up is the recommendation segment. This segment is designed for two purposes. The first is to express if I, Tim Cubbin, would personally tell you, my wonderful readers, to go out and get your hands on a copy of this book and read it. The second purpose is to describe what kind of interests a reader would have that would lead them to enjoy this book, besides fans of The Ultimates, Marvel, or the creative team. Let’s start with the first point. If you’re interested in reading this book now based solely on the words you’ve just spent the past few minutes reading, I would tell you to hop onto your favorite online retailer, or check a local bookstore, comic shop, or library, or try to see if anyone you know has this book because this book gets my recommendation, but it doesn’t get my highest one. As for the audiences who would most appreciate this book, I would say it would be people interested in mythology, or stories about wars on terrorism, military, espionage, or technology.

            Okay, we’re getting to the point where we’re almost ready to say goodbye. There’re a lot of things I do have to say first. First off, I’ve been doing this blog for almost six years now. In that time, I have posted 200 times. If you liked this post and have some free time, please continue exploring timcubbin.blogspot.com for tons of more content. I have written several short stories, poems, essays, articles, and editorials, as well as reviews of prose novels, manga, comic book events, and over seven dozen other Marvel Epic Collections. The current direction of this blog is to review Marvel Modern Era Epic Collections and Ultimate Epic Collections. I purchase each one as soon as I can after it is released, and if possible, put up a review as soon as I can after I finish reading it. I post on a very frequent basis, usually at least once every two months. If you liked this post and have some more time to kill and want to read a similar post, I invite you to search for my review of “The Ultimates: Super-Human” for more Ultimates content. I would like to state that I am aware that everything I say on my blog is my opinion. You are free to agree or disagree with me. If you’ve read this book and have differing opinions, feel free to leave a comment, or if you agree, I’d really like to know. I’d love to hear what my readers think. Please always feel free to drop a comment on anything you want to say, if you like my work, you don’t like what I’m doing, you want me to do something different, there’s something you want to see, anything at all, I’m always receptive. In case you’re wondering, my next post is going to be “The Amazing Spider-Man: Spider-Island” which you can expect to see posted within the next three weeks following this post. If you read with me all the way through this, you are THE BEST! I’m going to keep doing this blog for as long as I’m able to, so don’t expect this to stop anytime soon. I hope you’ll be back with me next time. Until then, Tim Cubbin… out!

Thursday, April 16, 2026

"Black Widow: Widowmaker"

 

                The following is a review of the graphic novel “Black Widow: Widowmaker” as presented in Marvel Modern Era Epic Collection format.

                Natalia Romanova was rescued as a baby by Ivan Petrovich Bezukhov in the former Soviet Union in 1928. In 1938, Ivan sent young Natalia to train with Taras Romanoff. Taras became like a father to Natalia. In 1940, James Howlett/Logan, the man who would become Wolverine, killed Taras. Natalia then worked in partnership with Ivan. In 1956, Ivan was gravely injured. James “Bucky” Barnes/Winter Soldier offered Ivan and Natalia a serum that would heal Ivan and extend both Ivan and Natalia’s life spans. Natalia accepted the offer, against Ivan’s wishes. In 1957, while training as a Black Widow agent in the Red Room, Natalia was introduced to Alexei Shostakov, the Soviet super soldier the Red Guardian. Alexei gave Natalia the nickname “Natasha.” Soon after, the two were wed. In 1963, the Soviet government faked Alexei’s death. Natalia went on to become a member of the Avengers and a superhero herself. Ivan continued to stay by her side. Though Natalia thought of Ivan as a father figure, Ivan had romantic feelings for Natalia. After repeated rejections after many years, Ivan finally left Natalia. Natalia eventually learned Alexei was alive. Years later, Natalia received a phone call from Ivan, warning her Icepick Protocol had been activated, right before he was murdered. When Natalia came to confirm the body was in fact Ivan’s, Ivan’s head was missing. Natalia went to Russia to try to learn about Icepick Protocol, and discovered that she had been implanted with nanites that could be passed on to the people she was close to, which could be passed of from those people as well, and could cause those infected with them to go into a psychotic rage. After saving Clint Barton/Hawkeye from his wife Bobbi Morse/Mockingbird and giving them the cure, Natalia went off to give the cure to others afflicted by the nanites. Superspy Nick Fury, former Director of S.H.I.E.L.D., gave Natalia the access codes to a H.A.M.M.E.R. government launch facility. Natalia broke in and flew to space, where she discovered a Soviet weapon called the Dreadnought floating in orbit over earth. Natalia discovered who the mastermind behind Icepick Protocol was, to her great horror, and was forced to face the past to save earth from nuclear annihilation.

                Natalia mysteriously received a black rose and a ribbon. She went to see her old spy contact the Black Rose to see if he was involved, be he denied any part in sending Natalia the items. On her way to see her boyfriend James Barnes/Captain America, she was attacked. Tony Stark/Iron Man had Wolverine investigate the attack. After finding the items, Wolverine returned to the hospital to watch Natalia after her surgery. Natalia escaped from the hospital. Tony Stark, Hawkeye, and Captain America learned that Natalia was attacked because Natalia had been implanted with a device that was recording information about superpowered individuals and was accused of selling their secrets to the highest bidder, and the device was extracted from inside of Natalia. Tony Stark’s assistant Virginia “Pepper” Potts was attacked by Maki Matsumoto/Lady Bullseye, and Natalia was framed for the attack. Natalia was attacked by Elektra Natchios, who was furious she had been spied on. Elektra let Natalia go after a fight to a standstill where Natalia told Elektra that she was not selling the information. After the fight, Natalia collapsed from her injury. Black Rose discovered Natalia and stitched Natalia up. Natalia flew to London, England to find Ned, son of the tech genius inventor of the device Natalia had been implanted with. Ned told Natalia Sumi was the man who had sold out Natalia to, and Sumi had bought Ned’s father’s tech out in exchange for money and a place to live. Sumi sent Russian agents Ninotchka and Boris after Natalia and Ned, and though Natalia was able to defeat the agents, she was unable to save Ned. Sumi taunted Natalia that Sumi knew about Natalia’s baby. While on a train, Natalia confronted Lady Bullseye, who she paralyzed with an injection and tried to learn who was behind Natalia’s predicament. Lady Bullseye did not give Natalia what she was hoping for. James found Natalia, but Natalia refused to let James get involved in her situation. Natalia visited the family of the woman who delivered Natalia’s stillborn child. In Munich, Germany, Natalia was confronted by a robotic body sent by Imus Champion, the man who was really Sumi. Natalia attacked the robot but was arrested afterwards by Captain America. Natalia escaped lockup, and the arrest had been planned by Natalia herself. Natalia then confronted Imus to the finish.

                Natalia went undercover to the opera to intercept a device for targeted assassinations, code-named “Tiny Dancer,” and deliver it to the Secret Intelligence Service. Natalia was surprised to discover what Tiny Dancer was and getting it to her clients was harder than she thought it would be.

                Tony Stark/Iron Man went undercover to Russia to recover stolen armor, with Natalia’s help. Tony went to make a deal in disguise but was caught by industrial spy Sunset Bain. Sunset hacked Tony’s brain and sent Tony in temporal armor to travel to the past to destroy Avengers Mansion at the first meeting of the Avengers, and Natalia had to find a way to shut down Tony’s brain to save the Avengers.

                Senator Whit Crane was running for vice president of the United States. He was seen with a mysterious “Woman in Black,” then dropped out of the race, and was found dead. His son Nick was a journalist and hoped to find the woman responsible for the death of his father. Kate Horsley/Fatale and Natalia both wanted to find out Nick’s source about the Woman in Black. Fatale got to Nick first and pretended to rescue Nick from the Black Widow. Natalia was able to separate Fatale and Nick and took Nick to a safe location. Natalia attempted to stage an abduction of both Natalia and Nick and bring them to a C.I.A. interrogation site in Poland run by a friend of Natalia’s to force the source out of Nick, but the staged abduction turned real. Nick and Natalia escaped the camp, but discovered Nick and Natalia were being framed for Senator Crane’s murder and went on the run. Nick and Natalia were on a train out of Poland when they were attacked by Russian agents Fantasma and Crimson Dynamo. Fatale rescued Nick and Natalia from the Russian agents. Nick told Natalia and Fatale that his source went by the name “Sadko.” Natalia and Fatale tracked Sadko to Bulgaria and teamed up to investigate Sadko’s true identity, but Sadko wanted Natalia and Fatale dead.

                An assassin called Ronin was striking the South Kuril Islands, islands that were disputed between Russia and Japan. Hawkeye and Mockingbird were investigation the death of a former S.H.I.E.L.D. agent, and discovered that there was a killer targeting spies, and Mockingbird and Black Widow were on the list. Hawkeye, Mockingbird, and Dominic Fortune went to Russia to meet up with Natalia, where they found themselves under attack. Natalia brought Hawkeye, Mockingbird, and Fortune to a Red Room training facility, where the killer had struck. Russian super agents Crimson Dynamo, Fantasma, Sputnik, and Perun attacked Natalia, Hawkeye, Mockingbird and Fortune, due to the fact that Hawkeye had previously claimed the Ronin costume and identity, but Hawkeye was innocent of these killings. After a grueling fight, Natalia and Hawkeye escaped, and Mockingbird and Fortune left on a plane to Japan. Natalia informed Hawkeye that Natalia knew the killer as Sadko. Natalia and Hawkeye encountered the Madame, and during their fight, Natalia deduced where and who the new Ronin was. Natalia, Hawkeye, Mockingbird and Fortune met up on Iturup and faced Ronin and his army at the foot of an active volcano.

                Natalia and Alaine Racine/Peregrine teamed up in France to rescue hostages from cyborg villain Rapido and stop terrorists from leveling London.

                Okay, we’ve now got our synopsis out of the way, let’s move on to the next phase of this review: my input. First off, we’re going to start with what I thought of this graphic novel. I will say that I found this book to be relatively enjoyable. I liked reading it. Let’s break it down storyline by storyline. “Deadly Origin” was interesting because it blended Natalia’s history with her present and revealed a lot of her background. It was fascinating learning some of the facets of her past that I didn’t previously know about, and the twist at the end of the storyline was great as her past actions inadvertently nearly caused nuclear annihilation. However, I didn’t like how the art of the flashbacks looked compared to the art from the present scenes. “The Name of the Rose” was actually my favorite storyline. I enjoyed reading as the mystery unravel. However, the artwork detracted from my visual enjoyment, but the story itself was good. “Coppelia” was short but sweet, and the Tiny Dancer’s actual purpose led to an interesting read. The artwork was also visually appealing to me, so that made the read entertaining. “Iron Widow” was a fun read, watching Tony Stark trying to change for his deal, and still getting set up even though he came in disguise. I also found the artwork in this issue to be satisfactory. “Kiss or Kill” was highly enjoyable, I loved how the story kept twisting and turning as it went on, and Fatale was an interesting character. I’m torn about the artwork in this storyline because sometimes it looked good to me, and then at other times I just didn’t like how it looked at all. The consistency of the quality of the artwork varied, and there were times where I liked the art, and times I didn’t. “Widowmaker” was a greatly entertaining story arc, Hawkeye is one of my favorite Avengers, and the team up was an exciting one. The true identity of Ronin was a twist I didn’t see coming, and the end battle was exciting. I also felt the artwork was great from both of the artists who penciled this storyline. “Fear Itself” was an interesting issue, seeing her take down a hostage crisis and stop a terrorist attack single-handedly was quite satisfying. However, the artwork itself wasn’t quite so satisfying for me. I also enjoyed how several of the storylines connected, even though they came from separate series. The continuity was much appreciated, and the continuing themes but featuring different characters made the read more interesting. Overall, I highly enjoyed reading the stories, but there were times where the artwork wasn’t so appealing. I also have to critique the choice of the title for this collection. My opinion is that the title should reflect the majority of the overall content of the book. The longest storyline in this collection was “The Name of the Rose,” but other options were “Deadly Origins,” “Kiss or Kill,” and “Widowmaker.” I honestly think any of the latter three choices would be appropriate titles for this collection, but if I were the editors, I probably would have leaned in more for “Deadly Origins” or “Kiss or Kill” for the title as I feel those represent this volume better. However, I still find myself able to support “Widowmaker” as the title, despite not feeling it was the best title for this collection. Finally in my examinations, we’re going to talk about the cover. I feel like the front cover should be an accurate preview of what the reader should expect to see in this collection, meaning it also represents the majority of the overall content of the book. This book sports a cover of Black Widow posing with two guns in the foreground, in front of a motorcycle, with Wolverine and Winter Soldier standing in the background. I feel like this book should have featured a cover with just Black Widow on it. While Wolverine and James Barnes are recurring supporting characters in this collection, I feel that this cover does not deliver on a promise of a team up with Black Widow, Wolverine and Winter Soldier as I came to expect from viewing the cover. I actually feel like that cover is highly misleading as there are few points where all three characters appear on the same panel in this collection, and James Barnes and does not appear alongside Wolverine as Winter Soldier at any point in this collection, just as Captain America, so I feel like the choice of cover was actually poor to use for a solo issue, and especially poor to use to represent this whole book. However, I do feel relatively positively about the book itself, based on story, but the art sometimes left a little to be desired.

                Next up, we’re going to discuss accessibility. I know some of you have been here before so you know what I’m about to explain, I’ve done it over seven dozen times at this point, but every time I do a new post, I know I have readers who have never been here before, so I have to do it once again, so if you do know this, just bear with me for a few sentences while I explain it to the newbs. So, the question I’m posing here is, is this book accessible? Accessible means can a person who knows absolutely nothing about Black Widow comics obtain a copy of this book, read it, and follow the story as it is written, with no difficulties? So, my answer to that question is yes. This book is extremely standalone. These are all limited series or one-shots that really don’t continue directly off of storylines from other series, with the exception of “Fear Itself: Black Widow,” but even that doesn’t feel to me like knowing the main event “Fear Itself” is actually a necessity to comprehend this issue. I don’t feel like having outside knowledge of Marvel Comics is essential to read this book. Despite this book being marketed as Vol. 2, every series in this book starts with issue #1, so there are no previous issues to any of the issues contained in this collection. If you are looking for a place to start reading Marvel Comics, I wouldn’t say this is the best starter book, but I feel it is definitely a book that a person who has never read a Marvel Comic book before can begin with.

                Next up, we’re going to move on to one of the core components of my review: the numeric score. I won’t say it’s the most important part of my review, everything in these reviews has some kind of essentiality for being in it, so I can’t say any one paragraph in this review is the reason everyone is reading this review for. However, this is, in my opinion, highly essential to my reviews and they would not be complete without it. So let me start off by explaining my scoring system. The system is extremely simple: I score on whole numbers ranging from one to ten. My lowest score is a one, and that means this book was so awful that every copy not sold should be immediately gathered up and obliterated, then all the prints that could be used to recreate this abomination should be wiped clean to prevent the continuation of this horrible piece of trash’s existence. Okay, that is extremely extra, but it illustrates my point that this book is just awful. However, if I give a score of a ten, that means this book is sheer perfection and I will never understand it if this book does not become a bestseller and if every copy doesn’t get sold and if it doesn’t have to get reprinted every few years. Now, I am very much not easy to please, and I will not give out a ten if a book truly is not perfection. So, what I’m looking for in a graphic novel is a constantly entertaining story, consistently appealing art, a title that perfectly captures the essence of the story, and a cover that accurately represents the content of the book. So we’ve established that I did enjoy the story, I found the art to be hit-and-miss, the title wasn’t absolutely perfect in my opinion, and I don’t believe the cover delivers on what it shows on the front of the book as actually being what comprises the majority of this book. So, looking at all of this, and putting it all together and churning out a score, what I have to rate this book at is… a seven! While the story was good, the artwork and the cover brought my score down a bit.

                Next up on our list of topics to discuss is the recommendation. In this paragraph, I answer two questions. Question number one is, do I, Tim Cubbin, personally recommend this book to you, my readers? Would I tell you, if you are interested in reading this book based solely on what I have just spent the past few hours writing, to go out to your nearby bookstore, or preferred online retailer, or favorite comic book shop, or local library, or Marvel fanatic friend or relative’s house, and procure this book and read it as soon as you possibly can? The second question is, regardless of if I would actually recommend this book personally, what kind of audience might appreciate this book, besides the obvious target group of fans of Marvel, Black Widow, or the creators? So, to answer the first question, yes, this book has my personal recommendation. I’d totally tell you to read it if my words have piqued your interest in perusing through this collection. To answer my second question, I think that this book would appeal to fans of spy stories, espionage stories, stories with mysteries, stories with lots of plot twists, and stories with a strong female lead.

                Okay, we’ve reached the point where I’m getting ready to wrap things up. There are a few things I would like to say before I go. I’ve been doing this blog for over five and a half years now. I’ve compiled over 180 posts, so keep checking out timcubbin.blogspot.com for more content. Over seven dozen of these posts are reviews of Epic Collections just like this one. I currently collect every Marvel Modern Era Epic Collection and Ultimate Epic Collection as soon as I can after its release and if possible, post a review. If you liked this post, feel free to check out my reviews of “Black Widow: The Itsy-Bitsy Spider” and “Black Widow: Chaos” for more content about Black Widow Modern Era Epic Collections. In addition to these reviews, I’ve also reviewed some prose novels, manga, and comic book events. I’ve also written short stories, poems, essays, articles, and editorials, so there’s other kinds of content to enjoy here as well. I post on a very frequent basis. My next post will be a review of “Ultimate X-Men: World Tour” you can expect to see that post sometime within the next two months following this post, most likely a lot sooner than that. I plan to keep doing this blog for as long as I can, so you can expect to keep seeing posts on this site for quite some time, unless I do something to prevent myself from being able to type. That’s all I have to say for now except Tim Cubbin… out!

Wednesday, October 15, 2025

"Captain America: The Burden of Dreams"

                The following is a review of the graphic novel “Captain America: The Burden of Dreams” as presented in Marvel Modern Era Epic Collection format.

                Steve Rogers/Captain America is dead. The Red Skull, with the help of megalomaniacal psychiatrist Doctor Faustus, manipulated Sharon Carter, former Agent 13 of S.H.I.E.L.D., into taking the life of the man she loved. Mentally blocked from telling anyone what she’d done, Sharon spiraled out of control, fighting to hold onto her sanity. But when she found out she was pregnant, she lost control of her mind again, shot her allies, Sam Wilson/Falcon, and Natasha Romanoff/Black Widow, and fled. Meanwhile, Bucky Barnes/Winter Soldier sought vengeance on the men he felt responsible for the death of Steve Rogers. But on his hunt, he fell into the hands of the Red Skull, who had secretly been sharing the mind of Bucky’s former master from his Winter Soldier days, ex-Soviet General Aleksander Lukin. Bucky was faced with Faustus’ mind-manipulation as well, but having been previously programmed, he was resistant. Falcon and Black Widow recovered on the S.H.I.E.L.D. Helicarrier, having only been stunned, leading Director Tony Stark/Iron Man, who was aware Sharon killed Steve, to believe Sharon was not completely gone. Falcon and Black Widow tracked the R.A.I.D. base where Faustus was hiding and infiltrated it. Faustus and Sharon escaped in an aircraft, taking Winter Soldier with them, but to cover their escape, Sharon kicked Winter Soldier out of the aircraft. Black Widow arrested the Winter Soldier, and the Winter Soldier was brought to the Helicarrier. Winter Soldier escaped and attacked Iron Man. The two fought until Iron Man talked him down. Iron Man showed Winter Soldier a letter left to him by Steve Rogers in the event of Rogers’ death, explaining Rogers’ wishes for there to be another Captain America and for Tony to save Bucky. Tony decided to kill two birds with one stone and make Bucky the new Captain America. Bucky agreed but said he would not work for S.H.I.E.L.D. Lukin faked his death in a plane crash. The new CEO of Lukin’s company Kronas Vladmir Morovin, who was secretly not even a real person, started to cause financial troubles for the American public by doubling oil prices and foreclosing mortgages. Stark was immediately suspicious about the existence of Morovin, but his theory was ignored. The new Captain America debuted against a R.A.I.D. faction. As a crowd demanded action from the government outside the White House, the S.H.I.E.L.D. agents stationed outside, who were under the programming of Faustus, went wild and attacked the crowd. Senator Gordon Wright contracted Kane-Meyer Securities, secretly a subsidiary of Kronas, to keep Washington, D.C. safe. Wright was under the influence of Faustus. A riot erupted outside the White House, and Captain America sprung into action to defuse it. As he entered the Senate Building, he was confronted by Synthia Shmidt/Sin, Brock Rumlow/Crossbones, and the Serpent Society. Captain America won the fight, but not the public’s affections. Arnim Zola, Red Skull’s scientist, discovered Sharon was pregnant. Sharon, who was fighting Faustus’ programming, discovered what appeared to be Steve Rogers alive in the Red Skull’s base. Red Skull deduced that Bucky was the new Captain America.

                Wright announced his candidacy for Presidency of the United States of America by forming the Third Wing Party. He negotiated with Kronas to halt the foreclosures and to reduce oil prices. This was all part of the Red Skull’s plan to take over and destroy America. Falcon confronted Stark, unhappy with Stark making Bucky the new Captain America. Clint Barton/Hawkeye confronted Bucky, telling Bucky Clint would be watching Bucky’s actions. Falcon came to Bucky and asked to team up with Bucky to save Sharon. Sharon came to rescue Steve, but discovered the person Red Skull was hiding was William Burnside, the Captain America of the 1950s, who was programmed to believe he was Steve Rogers. She was about to put him down but was discovered and stopped by Faustus. Falcon and Captain America confronted Zola at a R.A.I.D. base, and though the base was destroyed, Zola escaped. Sharon attempted to escape Red Skull’s base by taking a recovering Sin hostage. Bucky, who was following Wright, was confronted by Burnside. The two fought first, but Bucky tried to reason with Burnside and almost succeeded until Faustus reactivated Burnside’s programming. Sin fought off Sharon and stabbed Sharon in the stomach, causing Sharon to lose the baby. Red Skull turned on his daughter for ruining his plans. Red Skull had Zola working on a machine that would separate Red Skull from Lukin. Faustus decided to betray the Red Skull, causing Sharon to forget she was pregnant and releasing Sharon from Faustus’ control. Sin was tasked to take out Wright’s opponents at the presidential debate, but Sin, furious with her father, planned to take out Wright instead. Falcon and Black Widow discovered Red Skull’s base and infiltrated it. Red Skull’s machine failed. Burnside escaped. Red Skull set his base to explode. Falcon, Black Widow, Sharon, and Burnside had to stop Red Skull, Lukin and Zola, while Bucky had to stop Sin.

                Back in 1942, Steve Rogers/Captain America, Bucky and Jim Hammond/Human Torch saved Professor Zhang Chin. In 1968, the Winter Soldier was assigned to kill Chin, but Chin was saved by his experiment, the Man with No Face. In the present, Georges Batroc was hired by Chin to steal an archive drive from a United Nations Scientific Research Facility. Bucky was unable to prevent him from escaping. Captain America and Black Widow decided to investigate. Captain America found Batroc involved in a transport and tried to stop it and fought both Batroc and the Man with No Face. Captain America was almost defeated until Black Widow jumped in to help him, and the villains escaped. Captain America saw what was being transported and was furious.

                Bucky and Black Widow teamed up with Namor to go after Chin. Bucky decided to go in as the Winter Soldier. Bucky fought Chin’s agents and was abducted and brought to Chin’s laboratory. Chin created a virus from what he had stolen from the United Nations and planned to unleash it to eliminate half of earth’s population. He tested it airborne, and it was a success. He next attempted to transmit it through water and use it on Namor. Black Widow infiltrated Chin’s lab to rescue Bucky, and Bucky, Black Widow and Namor had to work together to stop Chin from releasing the virus and defeat the Man with No Face.

                Okay, now that we’ve got the plot summary out of the way, let’s progress to my input for this review. We’re going to start with my own personal opinions about this graphic novel. Honestly, I really enjoyed this graphic novel, and I looked back at previous reviews I wrote on the “The Death of Captain America” prose novel from several years ago and last year’s “Captain America: Death of the Dream” and I really enjoyed those as well. So, let’s talk about what I liked in particular. This book did have a lot of plot twists. I feel like Ed Brubaker wrote a compelling and cohesive story that wove past and present in perfectly. It was a big decision to kill Steve Rogers and replacing him with Bucky Barnes did seem like both an odd and logical choice at the same time. This gave Bucky a true shot at redemption for his actions as the Winter Soldier, and I did enjoy that, seeing him find himself again and be a hero. I don’t know if I’m more jaded now because of the MCU and future Captain America stories that I’ve read since where Sam Wilson was Captain America, and that in turn made having Bucky being Cap seem a little weird. I enjoyed how the supporting characters all had important roles in the drama as well and that the story wasn’t entirely centered on Bucky. I liked how the villains were written, the Red Skull’s machinations, Zola’s sycophantism, and Faustus’ betrayal were all excellent in my opinion. I thought the Red Skull’s plot with Wright, attempting to control America by getting his pawn elected President, was cleverly written. I found Chin to be an interesting mastermind. Watching Sharon throughout the course of the graphic novel was actually one of my favorite plotlines and I liked following her progression, even though it was full of tragedy, but it showed that a superhero’s non-powered girlfriend doesn’t always have to be helpless, which was what made her story so interesting, that she wasn’t just some damsel in distress, she actually fought for herself. I appreciated that Bucky wasn’t accepted as Captain America right away. If it were written that a superhero had just died and a new person showed up wearing a similar costume using the same name and everyone immediately loved them, that would be poor writing. Steve Rogers was Captain America since the 1940s and died, a guy who shows up in 2008 being the new Captain America should not be accepted in the mantle on his first public appearance. And I will say that I thought Bucky’s Captain America uniform was a lot cooler than Steve’s. I will say, though, that I was a little offput by the Superhuman Registration Act’s effect on Bucky’s ability to be officially backed by S.H.I.E.L.D., my longtime readers know how I am about unregistered heroes, and for those who don’t know, I’m actually pro-registration, so reading about an unregistered hero was a little bit of a turnoff. Now, I would be remiss in my duties reviewing a graphic novel if I didn’t discuss the visuals. As far as my liking of the artwork in this graphic novel, I found it to be acceptable. I’m not going to rave about it, I didn’t love it, but at the same time, I didn’t find it to be displeasing, I just thought that it was adequate and didn’t make perusing this graphic novel unappealing. I’d also like to touch on the title. I actually thought the title was perfect. There honestly were four given choices for a title, or the editors could have come up with something else, but I thought “The Burden of Dreams,” which was a title of one of the story arcs, was the best title the editors could have picked for this collection. I feel like it succinctly sums up the story, as Bucky takes up the mantle of Captain America and has to live up to the ideals of a symbol of a nation.

                Next up on our agenda is going to be the segment where I discuss accessibility. I know at this point I’ve explained this over six dozen times, but it’s something I always have to go over again for my newbs every time I do a review because I always have new readers who have never read a Tim Cubbin review before and may not know what I mean when I throw out the word accessibility like this. So when I say “accessibility” in association with a graphic novel, I mean if a person who has never heard of Captain America before can discover this book in their favorite bookstore, or website, or local library, or from a friend or relative, decide they want to read this book, then read the entire story and comprehend all the details they have just read. This book is extremely inaccessible. This collection is marketed as Vol. 3, and picks up in the middle of a story left off from Vol. 2, which had a storyline built from Vol. 1, so if you have not read the first two Modern Era Epic Collections of “Captain America,” do not try to read this volume. It is a direct continuation of an unfinished storyline, and you will have no idea what you are reading if this is the first Marvel graphic novel you ever pick up. This volume is absolutely not a place for a person who wants to begin reading Marvel Comic books to start with.

                We’re going to continue this review by me giving this graphic novel a numeric score. My scoring system is extremely simplistic. I score on a scale of one through ten, using exact integers. If I give a book a score of a one, that’s my lowest score, and that means that this book is a pile of trash that should be avoided at all costs. If I score a book at a ten, however, that’s my highest score, which means that this book is sheer perfection. When I review a graphic novel, I’m looking at a combination of three things: story, art, and title. The majority of the score usually goes to the story, while art and title will give point deductions if I don’t like them. I also am usually not one to give a book a ten unless I do truly feel the book is in fact perfection, so usually I start scoring a book at a nine and take my deductions from there. So, let’s quickly review what we’ve got going on here. I really enjoyed the story, I thought the art was acceptable, and I thought the title was spot on, so we’re looking at a relatively good score here. So, if I put all these factors together, the score I’m giving this graphic novel is… a seven! This may seem a little low, considering that I really did enjoy this book, but it is what I feel is appropriate.

                Next up is my recommendation segment. This covers two topics. The first topic is, do I personally recommend this book to anyone reading this review or to anyone unfortunate enough to have to hear me talk about this book in person? The second topic is regardless of the fact of if I would tell anyone to read this or not, who do I think is the best audience for this book? To answer the first question, yes, this book does get the personal Tim Cubbin recommendation. As for who I think the best audience is, we’ll look at the obvious first, fans of Captain America. Another target audience is fans of Ed Brubaker. Fans of Bucky Barnes/Winter Soldier would very much appreciate this story of his redemption and evolution as a character. Beyond that, I feel this book is good for readers of comics who like spy stories or tales of espionage. It’s also for comic readers who like political intrigue stories. Finally, I think it’s good for readers who like war and soldier stories.

                Okay, we’re getting to the point where I have said almost all I have to say. There are a few more things I have to touch on first. Let’s begin with the contents of this blog. I’ve been writing for five years now and have published over 175 posts. In addition to over six dozen other Marvel Epic Collection reviews, I’ve reviewed prose novels and manga, as well as written a few short stories, poems, articles, essays, and editorials, so if you want to try other material, keep checking out timcubbin.blogspot.com for plenty more content. I’ve previously written reviews of “Captain America: The Winter Soldier” and “Captain America: Death of the Dream” if you liked this post and want more Captain America content. I post on a very frequent basis as I purchase every Marvel Modern Era Epic Collection and Ultimate Epic Collection as soon as I can after they are released and try to post a review if possible. I usually do at least one post a month. I’m expecting to do a post of “Spider-Gwen: Ghost-Spider: Gwenon” sometime in the next two weeks, so keep an eye out for that post, and expect plenty more to keep coming as I’m going to keep doing this blog for as long as I possibly can, so that until I can’t see or type anymore, which I don’t expect to be a long time from now. I think that’s it for now, so until next time, Tim Cubbin… out!

Saturday, June 7, 2025

"The Ultimates: Super-Human"

 

            The following is a review of the graphic novel “The Ultimates: Super-Human” as presented in Marvel Ultimate Epic Collection format.

            In 1945, the Nazis had created a super-weapon that was aimed at Washington, D.C. that would potentially bring an end to World War II. The United States Army sent in a platoon to try to disable the weapon, led by a super-soldier named Steve Rogers, codenamed Captain America. Along with his teenage friend James “Bucky” Barnes, and the rest of the platoon, they charged on Germany. Not all of the platoon survived the assault, and they were unable to stop the weapon from being launched. Captain America jumped on the missile and detonated a grenade that knocked the missile off course and prevented it from hitting its target, and Captain America disappeared into the waters of the North Atlantic, leaving behind his fiancĂ© Gail Richards.

            In 2002, newly posted Director of S.H.I.E.L.D. General Nicholas Fury reignited the Super-Soldier Program with the hopes of preventing super-powered threats from becoming a problem for the United States of America. He met with Doctor Robert Bruce Banner, who had attempted to recreate the serum that turned Steve Rogers into Captain America and had instead turned Bruce into a creature called the Hulk. Bruce had been leading the Super-Soldier Research Facility in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, but when hired by S.H.I.E.L.D., the condition behind his substantial paycheck was he was demoted to number two, behind his prior assistant Henry “Hank” Pym. Hank was married to Janet “Jan” Pym, a mutant with the ability to shrink in size and gifted with wings, who also had some unfortunate bug-like qualities. Jan called herself the Wasp. Hank, using Jan’s DNA, had created a serum that allowed him to grow in size to almost sixty feet in height, the maximum height the human body can support. Hank took on the codename Giant Man. S.H.I.E.L.D. also hired tech genius businessman billionaire Anthony “Tony” Stark, who had an advanced technological suit of armor and assumed the identity Iron Man. Bruce’s ex Betty Ross was hired as the Director of Communications for the Super-Soldier Program. As they were preparing to move forward with the project, Captain America’s body was found frozen in the Arctic Ocean. Miraculously, Steve Rogers had survived frozen in ice for fifty-seven years and was able to be revived. At first, Steve was unaccepting of his new surroundings, and it took some convincing to acclimate him to now living in the 21st Century. Nick Fury brought Steve to the house of Bucky Barnes, now an old man and now married to Steve’s ex-fiancĂ©, Gail. While Steve and Bucky had a tearful reunion, Gail refused to come see Steve. Steve also found out most of his family had passed away in the fifty-seven years he had been in suspended animation. The Ultimates were announced at the Triskelion in the Upper Bay of Manhattan, their new headquarters. While Giant Man, Wasp, Iron Man and Captain America were introduced as the faces of the Ultimates, Fury was also attempting to recruit a man claiming to be Thor, Norse God of thunder, a protestor and former mental patient who was gaining notoriety in Norway and gaining a group of followers. Thor, however, refused to join Fury’s little gang. Held back from the launch were Clint Barton/Hawkeye and Natasha Romanoff/Black Widow, who were awaiting rewritten histories to cover up past indiscretions, and in the background were Pietro and Wanda Maximoff, Quicksilver and the Scarlet Witch, children of the mutant terrorist Magneto and former members of his Brotherhood of Mutants, who were unable to be shown as public faces due to their genetic statuses. Time went by after the launch of the Ultimates, but the team had no threats to face. While Betty began to move on from Bruce with Freddie Prinze, Jr., Bruce made the drastic decision to inject himself with Captain America’s blood and the Hulk serum. This created an even more powerful version of the Hulk, who went on a destructive rampage through Manhattan, fixated on finding Betty and winning her back for Bruce and removing Freddie Prinze, Jr. from the picture. Captain America, Iron Man, Giant Man, and the Wasp were dispatched to stop the Hulk, and Thor joined in to aid in the fight. The team was able to calm the Hulk and revert him back to Bruce Banner, and Bruce was put in a holding unit, while his identity as the Hulk was withheld from the public and the Ultimates were hailed as the heroes who saved Manhattan. As the Ultimates were invited to Tony’s penthouse for a black-tie dinner, Hank and Jan got into an argument that turned horribly violent. While Thor refused to accept a S.H.I.E.L.D. paycheck as a member of the Ultimates, he agreed to come to the aid if ever the need arose. Jan was taken to the hospital, and Hank was wanted for spousal abuse charges. Jan was quickly transferred back to the Triskelion, but her assault went public. Steve went out on a hunt for Hank. Clint, Natasha, Quicksilver and Scarlet Witch were introduced to Tony and Thor, who were all briefed on the presence on Earth of an alien race called the Chitauri since 1777, who were able to assume human form and had been in part responsible for the rise of the Nazis during World War II. S.H.I.E.L.D. had believed them to have been completely annihilated after World War II, but several Chitauri had then been discovered to be hiding on Earth. S.H.I.E.L.D.’s Psi-Division recovered the location of a Chitauri base near Micronesia. Before Fury could order against it, Steve found Hank in a bar in Chicago and had a S.H.I.E.L.D. team bring him to Hank’s location. Steve put the beat down on Hank, and Hank was apprehended. While in his holding unit, Bruce and Betty began to reconnect. Steve visited Jan in the Triskelion infirmary, but Steve’s actions against Hank and butting into Hank and Jan’s personal business only served to upset Jan. While Captain America, Thor, Iron Man, Black Widow and Fury flew with a S.H.I.E.L.D. Unit to Micronesia to assault the Chitauri base, Jan discovered that S.H.I.E.L.D. had already been infiltrated by the Chitauri, and their leader Kleiser was already on the Triskelion. Jan was caught by Kleiser and brought to the Chitauri base in the Arizona desert, while the Chitauri base in Micronesia was just a decoy base and was detonated, killing most of the S.H.I.E.L.D. Unit, but Thor had managed to teleport several of the Unit to safety, including Captain America, Iron Man, Black Widow and Nick Fury, and they arrived at the Arizona base. The Chitauri began their full-scale assault of Earth, with the intention of destroying the Earth. Captain America fought Kleiser, Iron Man and Thor flew in to stop the weapon, Black Widow came to rescue Jan, and Hulk was unleashed to destroy the invading ships and the Ultimates battled to save the Earth from the threat of Chitauri destruction.

            Okay, so now we have the synopsis out of the way, let’s get on to my own personal take on this graphic novel. Essentially the Ultimates are the Marvel Ultimate Universe version of the Avengers, but I will say that this is a vastly different take on their story, and I will also say that I found that to be a good thing. When Stan Lee created the Avengers back in 1963, they assembled by happenstance, all joining in to fight against a common threat and then realizing that working together as a team was beneficial. In Mark Millar’s Ultimates, the team is assembled by S.H.I.E.L.D. as a combat unit to fight threats ordinary units couldn’t. This is a completely different origin story. And I feel that it actually worked. I liked the idea of the Ultimates being a military unit. I thought the Hulk story was great, I loved Millar’s choice of hooking up Betty with Freddie Prinze, Jr., I thought that joke was pretty funny. I liked how Bruce and Betty’s relationship played out after that while Bruce was in a holding unit, it was actually quite humorous. I liked how Millar made Wasp secretly a mutant, but I wish he would have taken a little more of an opportunity to play up on that more than he actually did, it was just mentioned once and it was never brought up again throughout the rest of the graphic novel. I liked the concept of having a black ops unit within the Ultimates, keeping Black Widow, Hawkeye, Quicksilver and Scarlet Witch in the shadows because of their statuses keeping them from being public faces. I especially liked Quicksilver’s comments of how he and Scarlet Witch had actually been helping if you looked at the tapes and slowed them down, those gave me a good chuckle. I liked the Chitauri as the enemy that was the true test of the Ultimates as a team. I liked that Thor wouldn’t join S.H.I.E.L.D. on principal but would aid anyway because it was the right thing to do, and his characterization as a former mental patient now messiah activist was, in my opinion, rather brilliant, rather than just outright saying that this was truly the God of thunder. What I didn’t like was the spousal abuse story. I felt like Millar went a little too far with that one and that it was rather unnecessary with how graphically it was illustrated. I felt that it negatively portrayed mental illness, and I honestly did not approve of that storyline. I did enjoy Brian Hitch’s work as the artist, I thought he did an amazing job illustrating this graphic novel, I really like his artistic style. I loved how I read that Millar had told Hitch to make Nick Fury look like Samuel L. Jackson and that when Disney finally made the movies, they actually did contract Jackson to play Fury in the Marvel Cinematic Universe. I actually totally geeked out the first time I saw the post-credits scene in “Iron Man” when they introduced Jackson as Fury, having read this comic series after it was originally published back in 2002-2004 prior to the release of the “Iron Man” film and there was actually a scene in this graphic novel where the group discuss who would play them in films and Jackson was named as Fury. In general, I rather enjoyed this graphic novel.

            Next up on our agenda of things to discuss, we’re going to talk about accessibility. For those of you who know what I mean, please bear with me while I explain this to my new readers who have never read one of my reviews before and don’t know what I mean by using the word “accessibility.” So, what I mean by that is, if you know nothing about the Ultimates or Marvel Comics at all, can you pick up this book, read it, and understand what you’re reading? This is the first volume of the series from a universe that was relatively new at the time and had very little background history. It has no direct ties to any other series published by Marvel. There are no crossovers or events occurring during this graphic novel. It has a self-contained origin story. So, yes, this book is extremely accessible. If you’re new to Marvel and are looking for a good place to start, this is an exceptionally enjoyable book to pick up and begin your Marvel journey.

            Okay, now we’re going to get to the point that you’ve all been waiting for: my numeric score. So, my scoring system is extremely basic. I score on a scale of one to ten. One is the lowest score and means this book is complete trash and is not even worth reading. Ten is the highest score and means this book is perfection. On principal, I generally don’t give out tens very often because perfection is extremely hard to publish, but there have been occasions where I felt that this score is appropriate. As far as this book goes, I do not feel like a ten is an appropriate score for this book. I found some faults with the story, especially the spousal abuse storyline that highly detracted from my enjoyment of the story. And while I generally enjoyed Hitch’s art, there were moments where I felt like his artwork had a few mishaps. Unfortunately, there was also some content that doesn’t hold up over twenty years later, especially the inclusion of President Bush. But overall, I found this book to be high-quality and extremely enjoyable, so when I give it a score, I am compelled to score it at… an eight. It was entertaining to read, and the art was, for the most part, nice to look at. I feel like it deserves a particularly good score, but it’s not quite near perfection, so a minor deduction is required, but it shouldn’t be impacted harshly for the few problems I had with this book.

            Next up, we’re going to discuss if I give this book my personal Tim Cubbin recommendation, and then, regardless of that fact or not, whom do I think should be reading this book. If you’re guessing that I give this book my own personal recommendation, you would be absolutely correct. This book does, in fact, get my seal of approval. Moving on to whom do I recommend this book to, the answer is to anyone who likes the Avengers and wants to see a different take on what the team could be like. So, if you’ve never read a Marvel Comic book before and have an interest in the Avengers, I highly recommend you read this book, this is a totally interesting twist on their origin and worth the read. If you’re already a Marvel Comics fan and have never read this, I recommend this book to you, this is a whole new reimagining of what the Avengers could be, and I think you will enjoy this. If you’re just reading this review and have gained any vested interest in reading this graphic novel based solely on what you’re consuming right now, I’d recommend you get out there and pick up this book, if you enjoyed my review, you will definitely enjoy actually reading the entire story as there is obviously so much more than what I can describe on this blog and I think you should make the effort to get the complete story and enjoy this work for yourself.

            Well, I think we’ve gotten to the point where I’ve said pretty much all there is to say at the moment. There is a little more to add in conclusion, however, so don’t quite give up on me yet. First off, if you liked this post, there are over four dozen other reviews like this one to read, so keep checking out timcubbin.blogspot.com for more of my work. I am a huge collector of Marvel Epic Collections, I buy every Modern Era Epic Collection and Ultimate Epic Collection as soon as I can after they are released and if possible, I try to put up a review right after I finish reading them. So, obviously, I am going to be working with a lot of potential content. I currently have a Modern Era Epic Collection in my possession I am preparing to read, so you can expect to see a review of that one coming up some time in the next couple of weeks after this post, I have to finish reading it first, then find a day where I can actually sit down and write a review of it, but I will promise you it is coming soon. I have 160 other posts on this blog and there is no end in sight, so keep checking it out for more content if you’re interested. If you go really far back on my blog, I’ve actually written short stories, poetry, articles, essays, and editorials, but right now my main focus is on writing reviews. If you think these seem highly professional, it’s because I have a bachelor’s degree in English with a concentration in journalism, so writing this kind of thing is what I should professionally be doing, but due to circumstances, it’s not something I’ve actually been able to secure, so I currently work in a grocery store and work for free on a blog in my spare time. But it’s in my nature and I don’t mind doing it, it is the job I honestly should be doing but just can’t actually manage to get hired for due to the situation in my life that I don’t want to talk about and you honestly don’t care about. But enough about that. Keep checking back regularly for more, as there will definitely be plenty of upcoming content on the way, I’ll be doing this blog until I am physically unable to do it anymore, so that’s probably going to be a long time. I’ve already been doing this for five years at this point. And at this point, I’m just rambling on unnecessarily and boring you with useless details about my personal life that you really don’t want to know, so I’m going to let you go now and move on with your life while I move on with mine. But I will be back soon, and I hope you come back with me. And so, until next time, Tim Cubbin… out!

Monday, April 21, 2025

"Black Widow: The Itsy-Bitsy Spider"

 

            The following is a review of the graphic novel “Black Widow: The Itsy-Bitsy Spider” as presented in Marvel Modern Era Epic Collection format.

            Super spy Natalia Romonova/Natasha Romanov/Black Widow was sent to Rhapastan by both the Russian and American governments to kill French scientist Doctor Didier Ines, who had invented a bio-toxin he called the Deathless Frenzy. While on her mission, she encountered Yelena Belova, a student from the Red Room, the agency that trained Natasha. Yelena claimed to be the Black Widow and Natasha’s superior. The two fought, but their fight was interrupted by Rhapastani soldiers. The Russian and American governments also argued over who should keep the bio-toxin upon Natasha’s completion of the mission. Natasha decided not to kill Ines and instead have him work on an antidote to his serum. Both the Russian and American governments decided to eliminate Natasha for her double-cross. Natasha brought Ines to Zurich to work on the antidote but was followed by Yelena. The two fought again, but Natasha was shot by S.H.I.E.L.D. Agents. Matt Murdock/Daredevil informed Yelena that the Rhapastan military intended to use the Deathless Frenzy. Yelena went to Rhapastan to prevent this but was captured. Natasha was able to rescue her and complete the mission.

            S.H.I.E.L.D. abducted Yelena and performed a facial swap between her and Natasha. Yelena was placed in New York City as Natasha where she was hired to kill Yelena Belova. “Natasha” gunned down “Yelena” at the Museum of Natural History, but “Yelena’s” death was fake. “Natasha” became a fugitive, and “Yelena” was hired by Russian General Stelyenko to obtain five nukes that had been cached in the Hudson Valley during the Cold War, but Stelyenko knew that the Black Widow he had hired was not really Yelena and ordered his men to kill her. After his men failed to kill “Yelena,” Stelyenko arrived at the scene where “Natasha” learned how Stelyenko planned to betray Yelena. The two took down Stelyenko, then Natasha had to save Yelena from herself before the two swapped faces again and went back to their own lives.

            Yelena was sent to investigate the murder of Lieutenant Colonel Pyotr Starkovsky at a club. Starkovsky had trained Yelena and had been like a father to her. Her personnel files, which were top secret, had also gone missing, leaving the suspicion he was either selling or giving away information about the Black Widow. While on her mission, she found the murderer to be Petra, a woman who wanted to be the Black Widow herself.

            After retiring to Arizona, Natasha had a hit placed on her by the agency North Institute. She turned to her old contact Phil Dexter to identify the man who tried to kill her. Natasha learned of the murder of Stacy Matheson, a KGB deep-cover operative whose real name was Stefanya Melnikova and decided to attend her funeral and ordered Phil to come along for the ride. While at a gas station, Natasha rescued Sally Anne Carter from motorists. After the funeral, Natasha and Phil investigated Stacy’s house and found a hormone called Medusagen and military-issue medications. Natasha called Stacy’s friend Sergeant Will Forester to find out how Stacy was getting the medications, but a shootout killed Forester before Natasha could get the information she was looking for. Natasha learned the man who tried to kill her wore a ring that came from the Red Room. Meanwhile, North Agents Hunter and Kestrel were trying to track down Natasha and Phil. From Martin Ferris, Natasha learned of a liaison between the cosmetics company Gynacon and the Red Room and that she had to go to Moscow. While there, Natasha learned of her conditioning, and that some of her memories were false. Natasha met Lyudmila Kudrin, the woman in charge of the Red Room. Hunter and Kestrel found Phil and Sally Anne and shot them. Natasha returned to America with Lyudmila. She learned about North and went after the people who were following her, killing Hunter, and having a final faceoff with Vassily Ulyanov and Ian McMasters, the CEO of Gynacon, from whom she learned Sally Anne was alive and Natasha made it her mission to find the girl.

            Natasha traveled to Cuba to find Sally Anne. She hooked up with Yelena to get in. Kestrel wanted revenge for Hunter’s murder and recruited Ferris in her vendetta. Natasha sent Daredevil a tape to inform him she was fighting crime, which made the blind vigilante turn to S.H.I.E.L.D. Director Nick Fury for assistance in aiding his ex, which led them to Cuba. Meanwhile, Sally Anne woke up in a concentration camp for young girls in Cuba. Natasha attempted to come to her rescue but was herself held captive and tortured by Kestrel and Ferris. Natasha then had to escape with Sally Anne, along with the help of Daredevil and Yelena.

            Okay, so now that we have the synopsis out of the way, let’s get to my own personal part of this review. I will say that I found this book to be highly disappointing. When I bought this book, I looked at the size of it and saw how big it was and thought that so much would happen in it, but the stories were pretty stale and never went very far. The dialogue and action just never really progressed as a story. Yes, there was a lot, but it just never went anywhere. I found it to be relatively boring. And as far as the art goes, I found it to be mostly unenjoyable. The first three issues had art that I enjoyed, but after that, I just really wasn’t visually pleased. All in all, this book was just not a book that I liked.

            Next, we’re going to talk about accessibility. Now, I’ve said this about three dozen times already, but I know I always have to say it again for my new readers, so I’m going to do it. When I say accessibility, I mean just how easy it is for a person who has little to no experience with the subject matter to just pick up this book and fully comprehend everything they are reading. I will say that this book is highly accessible. It’s marketed as Vol. 1, and it honestly has no direct tie ins with any other stories and is completely standalone and self-contained, so I think even someone who has never touched a Marvel Comic Book before could just pick this us, read it, and follow the storylines with no real confusion.

            Next up, we’re going to get to the most important part of a Tim Cubbin review: the numeric score. I score on an extremely basic scale: one to ten, one being the worst and that this is absolute garbage, ten being this is one of the best books I have ever read. Obviously this book is not going to get a very good score from me based on the fact that I found the stories to be bland and the art to be unenjoyable. So, if I had to put this all in a blender and turn it on and churn out a numeric score, it would have to be a three. There was some enjoyability to this book, but honestly not much.

            We’re going to finish off on if I give this book a recommendation personally and regardless of that, to whom do I recommend this book? This book does not get the Tim Cubbin recommendation, and I honestly really don’t think I can recommend this book to too many people other than people who really are fans of Yelena Belova and want to read her earliest stories. Otherwise, in good faith, I can’t tell anyone to read this.

            Okay, I think we’ve said all that needs be said at this point. I will say that I have literally authored dozens of reviews just like this, and there are sure to be plenty more coming soon. Expect another one coming up in the next couple of weeks. I’ve also written short stories, essays, poetry, articles, and editorials, so there’s plenty more to see on this blog if you liked this post. Keep checking back for more, and if you come back again, you are THE BEST! I appreciate your support. Until next time, Tim Cubbin… out!

Saturday, April 13, 2024

"Black Widow: Chaos"

 

            The following is a review of the graphic novel “Black Widow: Chaos” as presented in Marvel Modern Era Epic Collection format.

            Natasha Romanoff/Black Widow is a superspy. She was trained in the Russian program the Red Room, which prepared young girls to be ruthless and dangerous operatives. She defected to the United States and assisted the government organization S.H.I.E.L.D., as well as serving as a member of the superhero team the Avengers. She has a lot of red in her ledger.

            After suffering from great guilt, she established the Web, a fund to benefit the families and friends of people she felt she wronged from her days traveling the wrong path. She hired a lawyer named Isaiah Ross to manage the transfer of the funds. To earn the money, Natasha went on missions, involving finding information, apprehending dangerous people, and occasionally taking out some bad guys. These missions brought her onto S.H.I.E.L.D.’s radar. Director Maria Hill, who had many trust issues, called in Natasha on a case. S.H.I.E.L.D. received a communication about “Chaos,” what they believed to be an organization, entity, or individual, and Hill felt Natasha was the person best suited for the job.

            The search for Chaos first led Natasha to a religious fanatical criminal named Molot. After their first encounter, which ended in Natasha’s defeat, Natasha needed information, so she turned to Tori Raven, an espionage expert. This information helped lead to Molot’s defeat but did not lead Natasha any closer to Chaos.

            Raven then gave Natasha info that led her to the Montenegrin Coast, where she found a moored freighter. Aboard the freighter was a man named Damon Dran. Natasha and S.H.I.E.L.D. were able to apprehend Dran, but Chaos ensured Dran could not provide S.H.I.E.L.D. with the information they were seeking.

            On a mission to rob a train in Prague, Natasha ran into Bucky Barnes/the Winter Soldier, Captain America’s sidekick turned Russian agent, who was on a mission to prevent the robbery. The two got into conflict, but ultimately realized they were on the same side.

            Natasha then went on a mission to a mobile tanker near Costa Rica, which being used as a satellite communications relay by the mercenary called Crossbones. As it turned out, she wasn’t the only one interested. Frank Castle/the Punisher had infiltrated Crossbones’ operation. But Crossbones wasn’t stupid and was covering his tracks and had set explosives throughout the tanker. The two managed to escape, but Natasha still had no new intel on Chaos. Then Natasha got a phone call from a man named Rashid, a man she had rescued years back, and who now had kidnapped Isaiah. To rescue Isaiah, Natasha teamed up with Laura Kinney/X-23, the clone of the mutant X-Man Wolverine, and went to a casino in Macau. The rescue was successful, but Rashid did not provide the info Natasha was after.

            Natasha’s life then became difficult after her dirty laundry was aired on national television while she was on a S.H.I.E.L.D. operation in Somalia. While at the same time, Isaiah was hospitalized.

            Tori Raven provided Natasha with information on Chaos. She had been working for them, and revealed Chaos was a financial organization. She provided Natasha with a list of their top accountants and told Natasha she had serious doubts Natasha could succeed without help. Natasha gave the list to Isaiah, instructing him to give it to Maria Hill. She then went on a hunt after the names on the list. This hunt reunited her with the Winter Soldier, and Natasha found Prophet, who showed her what could be her future, and Prophet revealed exactly what Chaos was. After finding what she was looking for, Natasha cut all ties, with her home, S.H.I.E.L.D., and Isaiah, and went off to find herself.

            Now, let’s talk about this book. When I purchased it, I wasn’t expecting it to be the greatest, and I was not surprised to find that I felt my assessment was correct and my expectations were met. I just felt like the story was so convoluted. I’ve never been a huge fan of spy novels or espionage movies. I’m not a fan of “James Bond” or “Mission Impossible” or anything else in that genre, so this book really was not going to be my cup of tea. I’m sorry to the writer Nathan Edmondson, I know you worked hard on this series, and I appreciate all the hard work and effort you put into this, but I just knew this wouldn’t appeal to me. You, my readers, may be wondering why, if I felt like I wouldn’t like this book, did I buy it? Honestly, I’m just buying all the Modern Era Epic Collections, so I wouldn’t pass on even a single one. I will say, however, that I was a fan of the art. I thought Phil Noto’s work was genius. The medium he used was watercolor paints, which was incredibly unique for a comic book. Traditionally when you think of comic book colors you think of ink, so this change was brilliant in my opinion, I was incredibly pleased by it. It was rather refreshing, so my hat is off to Mister Noto. I say it in my reviews of graphic novels that story and art are a partnership. A graphic novel is a union. You can have an exceptional story but have awful artwork and it totally ruins the book. Or you could have a horrible story, but the art is pleasant to look at. I’m getting a little ahead of myself here, but I do feel like that while the story didn’t appeal to me (I’m not saying I HATED the story per se), the artwork made me appreciate the book enough to find some enjoyment in it.

            Now, I always talk about accessibility when I write my reviews. What do I mean by that you may ask if you have never joined me before (and if you’ve graced this page before, bear with me for a few sentences)? Simple. If you’ve never heard of Marvel Comics before, or know nothing about Natasha Romanoff/Black Widow, can you still pick up this book and enjoy it? Now, the back of this book credits it as Vol. 3. I have to say to you: IGNORE IT! This could easily be Vol. 1. Marvel doesn’t always release their Modern Era Epic Collections chronologically, as you shall come to know as my reviews on these continue. Right now, the line is relatively new and there are not a lot of options, but the graphic novels are not published in order all the time. (I do have a few Modern Era Epic Collections in my possession I have yet to review, give it time, they will be there eventually). The first volumes of some of the titular series are not actually Vol. 1. “Daredevil: Underboss,” which has been previously reviewed, was the first collection published, yet it was Vol. 2. (We’ll get around to “Venom” around August, that will start with Vol. 4.) But let’s get back to “Black Widow.” This collects a complete twenty-issue series that was published between 2014-2015, plus a lead-in story and an issue of “Punisher.” I feel as if you know absolutely nothing about Mavel Comics, you could still follow this book. This book is completely standalone. It has no tie-ins to any other stories. Some Modern Era Epic Collections coincide with events and storylines that were ongoing at the time  and don’t actually contain any issues of the main event, just the issues focusing on one character/team from around that time period (take “Spider-Gwen: Ghost-Spider: Edge of Spider-Verse” for example, and I promise you there will be more, I already have a few volumes in my possession that crossover with events). You may have seen it with my reviews of the original Epic Collection formatted books. But again, I digress. This book focuses on just one narrative, and that’s it. I don’t find it to draw on knowledge of any previous Marvel storylines or storylines going on at the time, with the slight exception of the Punisher issue, but even that was a one-and-done. Yes, there are Avengers that pop up over the course of the book, but it doesn’t focus on any of their storylines. This book doesn’t dredge up any old Black Widow storylines either, it just focuses on the current story of Natasha and her mission to discover the truth about Chaos. I feel like it’s a perfect gateway Marvel graphic novel.

            Okay, now that we’ve got all that out of the way, you probably want to know my score of the book. Some of you may have noticed that this book hasn’t evoked as much of a discussion from me as some of my other prior Modern Era Epic Collection reviews. As I said, it has a singular storyline, and Natasha faces a lot of dead ends, so there’s really not a lot to mention, and if I did talk about that it would probably get a little boring. Plus, there is a lot of content that my blog site doesn’t allow me to discuss, so I had to leave that out. On top of that, there is a definite lack of dialogue and a surplus of action in this book, so there’s not a ton of story to discuss. There are several factors that kept this review slightly shorter than others, and I’d just be boring you explaining them, so I’m just going to move on. Now, my score. I score on a very simple scale, one to ten. One is the lowest, that means this book is trash and should be burned from existence and not reprinted, ten is the highest, that means this book is perfection. Now this score is, of course, my opinion. I don’t expect you to agree with me on my opinions. I highly invite you to disagree with me. Please feel free to leave a response in any of the proper formats possible if you’ve read this and have any opinions on this book, I’d love to hear them. I’m also a hard scorer, I don’t just go around handing out tens, but I’m also not an ogre and say everything is a one either. So, let’s balance this out here. So the story really didn’t interest me, there were a lot of false leads, it got confusing, there were points where what you were led to believe weren’t really what was going on, there was convolution, not a lot happened, there was a distinct lack of dialogue, all these factors detract from my score. And yet I really enjoyed the art, so the score is going to come up from there. Now, I’d hate to just throw out a low score, so I’m not going to do that. And I didn’t hate the book, but it just didn’t wow me. It was a little underwhelming, sure, but it was about what I expected. So, all cards on the table, story, and art combined, everything all in, I score this book at… five. Usually, I go on a little bit after about why I scored as I scored, but I think I’ve done enough already, so I don’t feel like I need to give any more reasons why I gave this book the rating I did.

            Next before I begin to wrap this up, I’ll tell you if I recommend the book. Honestly, I don’t. Not generally, anyway. If you’re not a regular reader of Marvel comics or even comic books in general, I’d really tell you not to go out of your way to get this. I really love Black Widow, I think she’s a fantastic character, but I still don’t feel like this was her at her best and I can’t just tell you to go out and buy this book, even if you are a huge Black Widow fan. I mean, if you ARE a HUGE Black Widow fan, then, yeah, you COULD read this book and YOU might like it, you’re entitled to your own opinion, this blog is all just mine. We’re all entitled to think whatever we want, so don’t let me stop you from potentially enjoying what you might think is a phenomenal book just because I didn’t like it. And, if you are into the whole spy/espionage genre, then yeah, I’d say this could potentially be a good read for you. But in general, I don’t recommend this book.

            Okay, I think it’s about time we wrapped this up. I’ve spent a lot of time digressing in this post, and for that I highly apologize, I honestly don’t mean to waste your time. If you’re still reading this review at this point, you are THE BEST! I really appreciate you! I hope you enjoyed this review. If you did, I’ve posted several dozen other book reviews on this site, feel free to check those out. I don’t have any more reviews planned for this month, unfortunately, but I will have one next month, so keep an eye out for it. I’ve also posted original short stories and poetry on this site, so feel free to check those out too if you have some time to kill. If you really want to waste time, I write B’ings, I haven’t done one of those in a long time, I feel like I’m overdue for some new ones. I write editorials, essays, and articles. I write other things, I just write what comes into my mind, as my blog site title implies. I have so much stuff planned, so keep coming back. And so, I say to you until next time, Tim Cubbin… out!

"Hulk: Fall of the Hulks"

              The following is a review of the graphic novel “Hulk: Fall of the Hulks” as presented in Marvel Modern Era Epic Collection for...