The following is a review of the
graphic novel “Daredevil: The Murdock Papers” as presented in Marvel Modern Era
Epic Collection format.
Alexander Bont had been an up-and-coming
mobster during prohibition. He went on to become the Kingpin of crime in New
York City. He ended the career of a crimefighter who called himself the
Defender. Matt Murdock/Daredevil helped play a part in Bont’s arrest. After
Bont got out on bail, Bont turned to Melvin Potter/Gladiator, one of the people
on his payroll. Bont offered Gladiator ownership of Gladiator’s shop in
exchange for the demise of Daredevil. Bont turned to Matt Murdock and his law
partner Franklin “Foggy” Nelson for legal representation, but Nelson and
Murdock were already involved in a case that qualified as a conflict of interest
with Bont. Daredevil fought and defeated Gladiator and learned the Bont had enticed
Gladiator into attempting to end Daredevil. Bont was found guilty in court and
sent to jail. Following this, another up-and-coming mobster named Wilson Fisk took
Bont’s place as New York City’s Kingpin of Crime. Years later, Daredevil
defeated Wilson Fisk and declared himself the Kingpin of Hell’s Kitchen. Bont
was released from prison and wanted to take his position back. He started
taking the street drug Mutant Growth Hormone to temporarily obtain superpowers
and ended the life of one of his former underlings, Slick Saul. Matt had been
outed in the press as Daredevil and Bont wanted revenge on the hero who put
Bont in prison. FBI Special Agent Angela Del Toro was assigned to the cases of investigating
Matt Murdock as Daredevil and of following Bont and was able to connect Bont
with Slick Saul’s ending. Del Toro had inherited the White Tiger amulets from
her deceased uncle Hector Ayala, the former White Tiger. Daredevil began training
Del Toro in using the powers the White Tiger amulets granted. Bont once again procured
Gladiator’s service and had Matt abducted. Del Toro came to Matt’s rescue and fought
Gladiator, and Matt faced Bont for the final time.
Reverand Bob Cumeo led a support
group for the people of Hell’s Kitchen to come discuss the effects of Daredevil
on their daily lives. One woman was present the night Daredevil took down Fisk
and shared the story of how Daredevil’s cleansing of crime in Hell’s Kitchen
changed this woman’s life for the better. One man in attendance had planted a
bomb in an attempt to destroy Daredevil. One woman shared a story of how her husband
was talked into committing crimes by a demon and defeated by Daredevil. This
led to an outbreak of violence between this woman and a victim of the woman’s
husband who came to the meeting just to have a confrontation and was furious to
hear such an outlandish story. Just as the group about to disband, another
woman in attendance pulled out her daughter’s drawing of the demon. The
supervillain Jonathan Powers/Jester had this demon inside him, and it spurred
him into holding a bank full of people hostage, including this woman’s
daughter. Daredevil had defeated Jester and the demon had escaped. To the group’s
surprise, one of the members in attendance was Matt Murdock, who had come to
the group looking for the man who had conjured the demon that had been inside
Jester and was inside a man in attendance of this same group. The man escaped
and Matt had a confrontation that ended both the conjurer and the demon.
Wilson Fisk spoke to Daily Bugle
reporter Ben Urich from Fisk’s prison cell. He wanted to make a deal with the
Federal Agents: he could leave the country with all of his assets unseized in
exchange for proving Matt Murdock was Daredevil. Agent Del Toro had a
conversation with the Director of the FBI, where the Director revealed he was planning
to take Fisk’s deal. The two argued, and Del Toro was fired. Natasha Romanov/Black
Widow went to S.H.I.E.L.D. Director Maria Hill to try to bargain for Hill to
squash the deal, but Hill refused. Matt reconnected with his ex-wife Milla
Donovan. Elektra Natchios, Matt’s ex-girlfriend, came to Matt after news about “The
Murdock Papers” broke. Fisk told the FBI director he had documented evidence
proving Matt Murdock, and Elektra wanted to help Matt get to it before the FBI
did. Black Widow agreed to help Daredevil and Elektra get the papers. Del Toro
also offered her support. Leland Owsley/Owl hired contract killer Bullseye to
kill Daredevil to prevent Fisk from getting his deal. Daredevil and Elektra beat
Bullseye, but Daredevil was shot by the mercenary Paladin, hired by the FBI. Fisk
revealed that there were no Murdock Papers and that it was all just a story he
told to keep his underlings and associates in line. Elektra brought Daredevil
to the Night Nurse, a nurse who secretly treated superheroes. Fisk surmised
thar Daredevil was taken to the Night Nurse, and Ben Urich, who had been brought
along on the deal, knew the location of the Night Nurse’s clinic, and to not
reveal this information would be an obstruction of justice that could get Urich
arrested. As Night Nurse struggled to save Daredevil’s life, Black Widow
brought Milla to the clinic. The ninja clan the Hand arrived and used their
magic to heal Daredevil. Luke Cage and Danny Rand/Iron Fist tried to prevent
the FBI from finding Daredevil. As chaos ensued, Daredevil revived and surrendered
to the FBI.
Okay, now that we’ve got the synopsis
out of the way, let’s move on to the Tim Cubbin segments of this review. We’re
going to start, as we usually do, with my personal opinions. First off, I will
say that I found this book to be pretty enjoyable. I found the stories to be relatively
interesting. I enjoyed “Golden Age,” the rise and fall and attempted reprisal
of Bont was entertaining. I really liked “Decalogue,” the support group stories
and the demon made for a compelling read. “The Murdock Papers” was engaging,
the deal with Fisk was a shocker, the twist that Fisk sent everyone on a wild
goose chase was a huge surprise, and the ending was just unbelievable. I feel
like Bendis did a very good job finishing his run. That said, I was not a fan
of the artwork done by Alex Maleev. I can compare his artwork to looking like a
colored sketchbook and it’s just a style I don’t like. As far as the title choice
for this book, there were the options “Golden Age,” “Decalogue,” “The Murdock
Papers,” or make up a title, and I feel like “The Murdock Papers” was the best
choice for this collection. While “Golden Age” could have worked, I think it doesn’t
sound as appealing as the title the editors chose, and “Decalogue” would not
have worked as a title for this collection in my opinion. I think the editors
picked right with “The Murdock Papers.” And it also was the longest story arc
in the book, although both “Golden Age” and “Decalogue” were five issues and “The
Murdock Papers” was six issues, so it’s not hugely a significant dominance, but
it still was longer even though only slightly. I do have to complain about the
choice of the cover. The cover chosen for this book depicts Daredevil swinging
in his original yellow and red costume, which is only seen in flashback
sequences in “Golden Age.” As such, I don’t feel it was an appropriate representation
for the book as a whole as it was seen briefly in a story arc that made up less
than one third of the book. I feel there were plenty of other covers in this
collection that could have been chosen that would have made a much more
accurate front cover for a book with this content. As far as story goes with
this book, I was generally satisfied, it was just the artwork that I found to
be disappointing.
Next up, we’re going to discuss
accessibility. Now I know at this point I have explained my usage of this word
over seven dozen times in my vast amount of reviews on this blog, but since
every time I write this review I have new readers, I have to explain myself
again each time because there are the newbs who might not understand what I mean
by my usage of the word. So when I’m posing the question “is ‘Daredevil: The
Murdock Papers’ accessible?,” what I’m asking is, can a person who knows
absolutely nothing about Daredevil or Marvel Comics in general see this book at
a bookstore, online retailer, comic shop, library, or friend/relative’s collection,
be intrigued by it, decide they want to read it, obtain it, read it, and understand
everything they’ve read without context? The answer to this is a huge no. This
book is marketed as Vol. 5, and it culminates a story that has been running
since Vol. 2 straight through. Not having read the previous three volumes in
the series is extremely detrimental to comprehending these storylines as these
stories continue directly from Vols. 2-4. If you have been following the series,
however, this volume is one-hundred percent accessible as it contains content
from only one series in order with no gaps, and it does not cross over into
other series or tie into any ongoing events. But if you have not read the entirety
of Bendis’ run prior to the start of this volume, I will tell you not to attempt
to read this volume at all, you have missed so much backstory and grasping all
the content will be extremely difficult. If you’ve never read a Marvel Comic
book before and are looking for a place to start reading, this is not your jump
on point. If you want to tackle this book with no other Marvel Comics history,
first read the Marvel Daredevil Modern Era Epic Collections “Underboss,” “Out,”
and “King of Hell’s Kitchen,” then you will be all prepared to dive headfirst
into this volume, but outside of that, I would not recommend reading this
graphic novel without consuming the previous three sequential volumes in the
series first. Some of my previous readers may recall I already wrote a review
of “Daredevil: The Devil in Cell-Block D,” which is actually Vol. 6 and was
released out of sequence, and if you read this review, you may recall my great
displeasure in this choice of marketing. Were they to have been released in
order, “The Devil in Cell-Block D” would probably have gotten a better review
as this volume leads directly into the next volume and this release plan makes
no sense and was very detrimental to my enjoyment of the story. I will
definitely tell you to read the Modern Era Epic Collections by volume numbers and
not by release date order.
Next up, I’m going to give this book
a numeric score. While some people read these reviews to know exactly how good I
think a book is, I can’t say this paragraph is the single most important
segment in my reviews, but it is very essential to my reviews. So, let’s discuss
my scoring system really quick. I score on an extremely basic scale: my scale
is a system of exact numbers ranging from one to ten. One is the lowest score I
can possibly give, and that means this book is awful, and that if I ran the
world, every unsold copy of this book would be rounded up and put on a massive
pile, then ignited and burned until they are nothing but ashes, then every possible
way to reprint this book would be wiped so this affront to the literary world
can never be reproduced and it will be extinguished from existence forever. Ten
is the highest score I can possibly give, and that means this book is sheer
perfection and that I will never understand if this book does not become a
bestseller that goes out of stock and has to be reprinted every three years. So,
when I’m scoring a book, I’m looking at four things: story, art, title, and
cover. All of these factors are taken into consideration when I make my scoring
verdict. So, with this book, we had a story I found generally enjoyable, art I found
entirely displeasing, a title I feel represented this book well, and a cover
that did not depict the overall content contained in the pages of this graphic
novel. This makes churning out a score somewhat difficult. But when mixing a
score for this book as a whole, taking everything into account, the score I’m going
to give out is… a seven. For the most part, I found the book to be literarily enjoyable,
just not artistically enjoyable.
Next up is going to be my
recommendation segment. Here I answer two questions. The first is, do I, Tim
Cubbin, personally recommend this book to you, my readers, or to anyone
unfortunate enough to get caught up in a conversation with me about this book?
The second question is, regardless of my answer to question number one, who do I
think, beyond the regular fandom of Marvel, Daredevil, comic book fans, or fans
of the creative team would most enjoy this graphic? To answer my first
question, I would answer yes with a caveat: read Vols. 2-4 first, then read
this volume. If what I’ve been writing for the past few hours has you
interested in reading this book, I tell you to go for it, as long as you read all
of the previous parts of Bendis’ run first and read it as an entirety of his
work on Daredevil. As for an audience whom I think might enjoy this graphic
novel, I would say that fans of crime graphic novels would find this appealing,
especially the mob, as the Bont flashback sequences pertain to prohibition and
mobster fans would probably find those segments particularly enjoyable. “Decalogue”
actually hold religious connotations, so Catholic or Christian graphic novel
fans might enjoy it as it is framed around the Ten Commandments and features a
satanic presence. Espionage fans would also possibly find this enjoyable, with
the FBI going after Daredevil and the Black Widow getting involved. And fans of
legal dramas might find this interesting as Daredevil’s alter ego is a lawyer
and “The Murdock Papers” has a huge focus on the law.
Okay, we’re at the point where we’re
just about finished. There are a few more things I have to say before I log off
and click post. First off, I’ve been doing this blog for over five years and
have accumulated over 180 posts. Over seven dozen of them are reviews of Epic
Collections just like this one. I’ve also reviewed prose novels and manga in
the past. I’ve also drafted short stories, poetry, essays, articles, and
editorials, so there’s a variety of content on this blog if you’re looking for
a change of pace. My current main focus however is to review Marvel Modern Era Epic
Collections and Ultimate Epic Collections. I purchase each one as soon as I can
after it is released and review it as quickly as possible. If you liked this
particular review, feel free to search for my reviews of “Daredevil: Underboss,”
“Daredevil: Out,” “Daredevil: The King of Hell’s Kitchen,” and “Daredevil: The Devil
in Cell-Block D” for more Daredevil content. My next review is going to be “Ultimate
Spider-Man: Hunted” you can expect to see this post within the next two months
from the date of this posting. I plan to keep doing this blog for as long as
possible, which will be until I am no longer capable of typing, so expect this
to keep going for quite a while. That’s all I have to say for now. Until next
time, Tim Cubbin… out!